Stuff-A-Bagel

Reviews about Stuff-A-Bagel

• 2 / 5

  By Kristen Sheridan
  I have ordered a number of egg sandwiches from stuff a bagel in east Islip since the new ownership and have not once been satisfied with the outcome. My husband and I ordered two sandwiches on Saturday morning, one was bacon egg and cheese on an everything bagel and the other egg whites bacon and cheese on a wheat bagel with ketchup. It was by far the messiest, greasiest meal ever and both of us didn't even finish them. The egg were all chopped up and fell off the bagel, ketchup everywhere and the bagel was greasy to the touch. Unfortunately, this is not the first time this has happened, but I keep returning assuming it will get better, but since it doesn't we will NOT be returning customers in the future. Disappointing since Stuff a bagel always had such a good reputation!
  May 25, 2017
• 1 / 5

  By Corinne Hendricks
  I usually go somewhere in my town but since I wasn't around there I decided to try this place. I got three bagels -two with cream cheese, one with butter. All three bagels were cold, hard, and barely had any cream cheese and butter on them. I almost asked for light cream cheese because I'm used to the large amount that other bagel stores will give you but this was just dissapointing. I also got two strawberry milk and it was over 10$. For the price I payed these bagels were just terrible. I would recommend going somewhere else. Or picking which bagel you exactly want and how much cream cheese or butter you want on it.
  February 01, 2017
• 5 / 5

  By Thomas Coe
  Awesome food & clean.
  January 04, 2017